Two ways a verdict could be built on evidence the tool did not actually have.
Pooling only ever upgraded provenance: one node that knew its training range set
the pooled flag, so a cell whose other nodes could not prove a range was still
reported as evaluated, and a cell could pass with no evaluated range at all. A
node with an unknown or unusable range now marks the pooled cell incomplete,
zeroes the displayed range (no range is shown that only some nodes could prove),
and appends "provenance incomplete: N of M contributing node report(s)". A known
range can no longer upgrade an unknown cell.
The documented "passes only if all 9 cells pass" was not enforced: passed was
just "some cells and not refused", so a one-seed, one-period report set exited 0.
A completeness gate now requires 3 seeds, 3 periods contiguous from 0, the full
seed x period cross product, and per-report consistency, and names every reason
("need 3 training seeds...", "missing: seed3 period 2", "inconsistent
--eval-model / --periods across node reports") before any verdict is computed.
Four findings from a four-lane audit made the promotion gate unable to support
its own claims.
In-sample evaluation: training walks the whole post-warm-up store and the gate
evaluates the same windows, with nothing checking provenance - replay.cpp itself
listed point_in_time_splits_and_overlap_not_assessed. Models now record the
window range they learned from (file format v2; v1 still loads as unknown) and a
content fingerprint, evaluation reports its own range plus in_sample, and
promotion_gate fails with the reason: an overlapping range, no recorded range,
or no digest. Unprovable provenance never counts as out-of-sample.
Degenerate baseline: with rarity-greedy on 0 hits, hits_per_cpu_second() returns
0.0, so ">= 1.5x rarity" reduced to "model hit something" and the recall check
was vacuous. A cell whose baseline scored no hits or spent no CPU now fails,
naming the budget refusals that starved it.
Stale models: cells keyed on a bare filename, so a later cycle that refused to
train left an older cycle's dist/gate models to be judged, and nothing bound a
verdict to the file it judged. Cells and reports carry the model digest, and
fleet gate sets refused (non-zero exit) for a cell without one or for a
(model, period) whose digests disagree across nodes instead of pooling them.
3 seeds are not generalization: they vary initialisation and the per-node
shuffle over identical windows. The procedure document now says so and states
what would test generalization (disjoint periods, models trained on an earlier
cut, out-of-sample ranges).
Tests: in-sample flagged, disjoint range not flagged, unprovable provenance
fails, 0-hit and 0-CPU baselines fail, mixed digests refused, legacy report
refused, range round-trip and fingerprint, v1 compatibility.
The pre-registered gate (docs/evaluation/stage4-promotion-gate.md) asks for the
criteria to hold on 3 non-overlapping periods x 3 training seeds; until now the
tool reported a single run and the operator recorded the rest. This produces
the 9 results for a fleet, with the criteria unchanged:
- replay --policy-eval --eval-model FILE (repeatable) --periods N: one pass
evaluates every model on every equal time slice of the ranked history; each
(model, period) cell simulates the model and rarity-greedy with their own
hourly budgets exactly as policy_eval does (policy_eval.cells). With one
model equal to --model and one period the cell equals the single-model
evaluation (test R11b); periods partition windows and positives.
- strawberry fleet gate DIR: pools the cells of every node report (windows,
positives, inspections, CPU-s, hits, refusals) per (model, period) and
applies learn::promotion_gate unchanged to each; passes only if all pass.
Malformed / cell-less reports are skipped and listed.
- Evaluation stays on the node (raw telemetry never leaves it): the central
cycle now also publishes all three seed models to dist/gate/; strawberry.gate
(sensors) evaluates them with the pre-registered evaluation traces; the
operator-run orch.strawberry_gate pushes the reports back and pools them;
evidence under central.work_dir/gate-<stamp>/. Nothing promotes.
- docs/evaluation/stage4-fleet-gate.md: the procedure (new dated document;
criteria and numbers unchanged).
Validated: test_fleet_gate (pooling sums, pooling reaching 10 positives
neither node has alone, one failing cell fails the fleet, malformed reports
skipped), R11b, Salt render checks (no models -> refusal; 3 models x 3
periods; orchestration pools), and scripts/fleet_e2e.sh end to end: 3 nodes ->
9 pooled cells with 28-50 positives each; the untrained synthetic models
correctly do not pass (exit code matches the verdict).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>